
Okay everyone, time to get a little controversial!
I logged onto my computer this morning and saw this article staring me in the face. I thought it would make a good discussion topic!
So, do YOU think that Sony crossed a line with this? Here's what I think.
While I think there are better games Sony could have created, I am not personally offended by this video game just because I am a fat person. In fact, my first reaction was to chuckle to myself a bit. I mean if you stuff yourself with cake you are going to become tired, fat and hard to move! But then I am a person who is able to (or at the very least is learning to) poke a little fun at myself and life.
There are two ways someone can look at this silly game. On one hand, it could be taken as an attack against fat people and a means of "creating a new generation of fat-hating, heteronormative ---holes" (though I wonder if these feminist groups would have gotten as upset if the character were a Fat King? After all fat hating is fat hating weather it's man or woman right?) Or, one can look at it as a humorous way of raising awareness of one of our country's biggest problems (yes pun intended). Sometimes a stupid depiction of something can make us realize that while we might not like it, a change in how we live our lives is necessary.
I mean hell, if I find myself stuck in the kitchen eating a whole cake (which I've been known to do) I know I'll gain weight and won't be able to run after my little minions as well as I should be able to! And you never know, it might make the couch potato kid playing this game think twice about his or her food choices. Maybe it will motivate him or her to put down the sweets and go outside to play so they don't end up becoming a "fat princess" themselves. Coming from a parent, "No cake, go out and play," would sound like a nag. Even worse is the growing number of parents that don't even bother teaching their kids about health or nutrition because they don't want to have to change their own unhealthy habits. But what if a game like this actually helps some kids to make a connection for themselves via a medium they relate to? That could end up sending a powerful, and in that case positive message.
And from a feminist standpoint, I'd think they'd be more upset by the fact that they are using the princess as the flag or prize to be captured than they would be about her being fat. You eat a ton of cake you get fat, that's fact. But isn't it worse to imply that women are trophies to be captured?
So what do you think? Are you offended? Not offended? Think it's funny, mean or just plain stupid? I'd love to know what you guys think.

5 comments:
I'm not offended by this either, but it's a shame that the creatives over at Sony put their heads together and came up with this. If young girls play this, then yes- this does reinforce fat=bad. If young boys play this, it puts the notion in their head that fat girls aren't as capable/desirable as thinner girls.
It's unfortunate that kids spend more time playing video games than playing outside. This makes them more impressionable in front of the television. With everything that's going on in the world and all the possibilities to teach them something positive via video games, it's a shame Sony chose this route.
Okay, so maybe I am a little more annoyed by it than I originally though, haha. At our age, we know what to believe and what not to believe. But the younger you are, the less children think for themselves.
Thanks for your reply Kristen. I have to say, while I wasn't offended by this,it's not a game I would have pitched to Sony myself.
You bring up a good point though...one that I have another controversial article on that I will post another day. The concept of "Fat Acceptance."
Not that I'm saying that it's even remotely okay to ridicule or belittle someone for being overweight, I do think that there is a fine line where acceptance ends and enouraging people to believe it's okay to be overweight and living an unhealthy lifestyle is okay begins.
However when you take a kid who is fat because their parents fed them tons of crap and never encouraged them to eat healthy or get out and move, now we have a problem. A child like that will feel like less of a person if they internalize the message that fat=bad. That is no good either. However someone needs to teach the child that they have their own power to make healthy choices instead of just merely teaching them that they are a valuable person even though they are fat.
Perhaps Sony should have added a feature in this game where if you fed the princess healthy food she'd have more energy to fend off attackers!
By the way Kristin, I can't view your blog for some reason..would you mind sending me the link so I can check it out?
I actually don't have a blog anymore - I created this account when I was a bridesmaid...the bridal party all created accounts and contributed to a private blog instead of sending very long email chains and clogging up our inboxes. I actually have been thinking of starting a blog again, but I honestly don't know what I'd write about...I just get bored at work sometimes and feel like I've surfed to the end of the web and back, haha.
BTW, I'm the Kristen that emailed you, Jen's friend. :)
I've read several fat acceptance blogs and am somewhat familiar with it. I do believe that there needs to be more positive attention focused on the fact that people can be overweight and lead healthy lifestyles. Too often there's a negative connotation associated with being overweight. You're right,instead of teaching children junk food & no exercise=fat=bad, there should be more emphasis on making healthy choices, which absolutely can include having a few cookies or ice cream every once in awhile.
I completely agree that Sony should have considered features that included healthier choices, which could have led to excelling in the game.
One more thing! I read this blog and have found it to be pretty relevant to my struggles, and I thought maybe you'd like to read it too:
http://talesofadisorderedeater.org/
:)
This game is pretty effing stupid, but I think there are more important things to get my panties in a twist over.